Volume 29, Issue 1

“There’s An Iowa Kind of Special”: Opportunities for Women in State Government in the Wake of SF 2096

Monday, June 1, 2026
Iowa went from being the only state to require gender balancing at all levels to having no gender balancing. In 2024, Iowa legislators passed Senate File (SF) 2096, removing gender balancing requirements from the appointment process for state boards and commissions. Subsequently, § 69.16A was struck from the Iowa Code, thereby removing gender balancing requirements. This repeal will create discrimination against women akin to the pre-§ 69.16A-era, reducing their political participation overall. Reinstating § 69.16A, or similar language, would ensure stronger opportunities for women in politics. While gender balancing legislation has not been found to increase the number of women involved in politics over time, Iowa’s repeal of gender balancing language does not bode well for women’s participation on state boards and commissions or in higher elected political offices, where such boards could serve as a springboard. Iowa should comprehensively address ways to increase women’s participation in politics, like stronger family support policies and building trust in government institutions. § 69.16A or similar language should be reinstated in the Iowa Code as a part of that effort to continue to provide more opportunities for women in government, for our “Iowa kind of special.”

“Good” and “Moral” Victims: How the Violence Against Women Act’s Self-Petition Reflects the Intersections of Violence and Crimmigration

Monday, June 1, 2026
The Violence Against Women Act (VAWA)’s self-petition process serves as a vital form of protection for undocumented survivors, allowing battered spouses, children, and parents of United States citizens or lawful immigrant abusers to independently petition for lawful immigration status—provided they prove their “good moral character” under the law. In recent decades, immigration law has increasingly adopted a securitized framework that mirrors criminal law enforcement, giving rise to what has been coined “crimmigration,” or the convergence of criminal and immigration law that classifies undocumented immigrants as “criminally alien,” and therefore, deserving of detention, incarceration, or expulsion. The emergence of America’s draconian and retributive crime policies, crimmigration, and the VAWA self-petition has created significant challenges for those with prior criminal histories, arrests, or convictions in demonstrating their “good moral character” (GMC), a requirement imperative to the self-petition process. As it exists, the VAWA self-petition is not adequately structured to provide formerly incarcerated or convicted immigrants with a viable success path towards lawful immigrant status. While VAWA can serve as an effective tool for supporting victims of domestic and gender-based violence without reinforcing or expanding carceral mechanisms, it needs to be reformed. Ultimately, this Note advocates for a four-pronged solution to restructuring the self-petition: (1) a reevaluation of the GMC standard; (2) a congressional amendment to the Immigration and Nationality Act’s language regarding GMC; (3) a context-specific and trauma informed U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) adjudicative process; and (4) a reallocation of VAWA’s funding towards community-oriented organizations and resources.

How Iowa’s “Revenge Porn” and AI-Generated Porn Laws Disproportionately Harm Women and Minors

Monday, June 1, 2026
In 2024, Iowa legislators passed House File 526 and became the 35th state to criminalize nonconsensual pornography. The law makes it a crime “to employ, use, persuade, induce, entice, coerce, solicit, knowingly permit, or otherwise cause or attempt to cause a minor or a law enforcement officer or agent posing as a minor to engage in a prohibited sexual act or in the simulation of a prohibited sexual act.” This law requires the perpetrator to “know, or have reason to know, or intend that the act or simulated act may be photographed, filmed, or otherwise preserved in a visual depiction.” However, this law fails to adequately address the disparities women and girls face from perpetrators that disseminate nonconsensual pornography (“revenge porn”) because offenders often use a third party, such as a website, to distribute the nonconsensual pornography. As a result, no party is charged because the distributor did not know or have reason to know the pornography was non-consensual, and the offender is able to hide behind a third party to escape liability. Nonconsensual pornography is more often perpetrated by men, while women and girls are more likely to be victims and face harsher consequences resulting from victimization. These disparities are exacerbated by rape culture, where sexual consent is assumed, and women are not believed when they come forward to report an assault, especially if they have engaged in consensual sexual acts in the past with or without the same partner. Given the immense social consequences women and minors face in pursuing a legal remedy, Iowa legislators should seek to minimize these disparities and produce equitable results, so victims are encouraged, rather than punished, for speaking up about crimes committed against them.

Laws Enacted Will Stay Enacted: Why are Mandatory Arrest Laws Still Commonplace?

Monday, June 1, 2026
Mandatory arrest laws, which require that a police officer make an arrest if they have probable cause to believe that a crime of domestic violence has been committed, were once widely embraced as a tool for curtailing domestic violence. States rushed to pass these laws, while academics and advocates generally applauded such efforts. But almost as quickly as these laws were enacted, their perverse consequences began to emerge. Today, a consensus exists that mandatory arrest laws do not protect victims of domestic violence, nor do they deter these crimes. Experts agree that mandatory arrest laws pose significant harmful consequences and have advocated for their repeal. Advocacy groups that once championed these laws no longer defend them, and the federal government has silently stopped promoting them. All of this poses the question: why have states not repealed their mandatory arrest laws? These laws remain on the books in twenty-nine states and the District of Columbia, with sixteen of those jurisdictions requiring at least one arrest if there is probable cause to believe abuse occurred, no matter the circumstances. This Article takes a comprehensive look at how the dialogue surrounding mandatory arrest laws has changed—and why these laws are still on the books. It sheds light on the pervasive gap between the consensus among scholars and activists that mandatory arrest laws are more harmful than helpful and the persistence of these laws. It argues that the endurance of these laws is partly a product of a perverse incentive structure and the shortcomings of the legislative process.

From Opt-In to Opt-Out: Legal Representation in Involuntary Hospitalization in Israel and the United States

Monday, June 1, 2026
Involuntary hospitalization of individuals with mental health disorders raises legal and ethical issues, particularly concerning the balance between the right to due process and patient autonomy, and the need to ensure optimal care while preventing harm. In Israel, the right to legal representation in involuntary hospitalization proceedings aims to mitigate the infringement on patients’ rights. This Article examines the current Opt-In model of legal representation in some U.S. states and presents the advantages of the Opt-Out model in Israel, in which representation is provided by default, preserving the patient’s right to refuse. Findings from a unique empirical study indicate that the Opt-Out model increases access to legal representation and enhances procedural fairness. The Article also compares various legal approaches by examining models implemented in the U.S. It offers practical recommendations for adopting the Opt-Out model in Israel and U.S. states in which the Opt-Out model is implemented. It proposes oversight mechanisms to ensure informed decision-making and points out the importance of balancing patients’ rights and the need to safeguard their health and well-being.

On Women’s Autonomy: From Muller to Dobbs

Monday, June 1, 2026
This Article studies the way women’s autonomy is limited in two contexts: contract and abortion. In cases of both freedom of contract and reproductive freedom, the courts employ a narrow, individualistic notion of autonomy, balanced against other policy considerations. Since both the notion of autonomy and the way it is balanced against competing interests are gendered, women’s autonomy is restricted. To better protect women’s autonomy, this Article suggests applying a relational and more complex notion of autonomy. Relational autonomy would consider the social relations that constitute women’s autonomy—including oppression—and propose ways to restructure these relations to enhance autonomy. Contrary to a freedom-public policy binary, relational autonomy provides a more comprehensive notion of autonomy, enabling consideration of the many conflicting values while not pitting one against the other.

Good Intentions, Mixed Messages: Considering Mental Health in Attorney Discipline

Monday, June 1, 2026
The legal profession urges struggling lawyers to seek help—but what happens when those same lawyers become the subject of discipline? As mental health challenges among lawyers become more widely acknowledged and understood, the disciplinary systems that govern the profession remain uneven and opaque in their treatment of mental health as a mitigating factor. This Article presents the first comprehensive review of over a decade of disciplinary decisions and admonitions in Massachusetts, focusing on how mental health is considered during sanctioning and whether current standards meaningfully reflect the profession’s stated commitments to fairness, public protection, and attorney well-being. The analysis reveals that mental health mitigation is marked by deep ambiguity and inconsistent application. Central to the confusion is the requirement that attorneys demonstrate a “causal and temporal” connection between their condition and the misconduct, as well as some form of successful treatment or recovery—standards that often assume a neat narrative of decline, diagnosis, treatment, and recovery. Yet for many attorneys, mental health conditions are chronic, cyclical, or resistant to linear resolution. Those who were actively in treatment at the time of misconduct—or whose recovery does not fit a prescribed model—are often left navigating unclear or even contradictory expectations. Is recovery required for mitigation? And if so, what counts as “recovery”? Is it symptom alleviation, responsible engagement with treatment, or something more? Massachusetts case law references all three, from the “alleviation of symptoms” standard in Roper, to the “responsible addressing” language of the Massachusetts Bar Discipline Manual, to the American Bar Association’s requirement of “demonstrated rehabilitation.” These inconsistent standards not only confuse but constrain: they risk turning recovery into a gatekeeping device rather than a path toward reform. These inconsistent and unclear standards also pose challenges for disciplinary bodies. These uncertainties matter—not just for individual fairness, but for the legitimacy and integrity of the disciplinary system itself. Vague or rigid standards for causation and recovery introduce procedural unfairness, discourage help-seeking, and reinforce stigma by penalizing those whose conditions defy easy resolution. While disciplinary boards may understandably hesitate to adopt more detailed guidance due to the complexity of mental illness, this Article argues that such complexity demands clarity, not avoidance. In the absence of transparent and flexible standards, ambiguity risks becoming its own form of punishment or deterrence. The Article concludes by exploring possible reforms aimed at building a more just and coherent system—one that clarifies evidentiary expectations, recognizes the realities of chronic and episodic conditions, and better integrates the expertise of medical and mental health professionals. If the profession genuinely seeks to promote lawyer well-being, its regulatory structures must reflect that commitment—not just in rhetoric, but in rules. At a time when the profession urges lawyers to seek help, our regulatory systems must be evaluated to ensure they do not punish those who do.